Legal Guardianship vs. Adoption: What’s Right for You?

Share this article

Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on email


Legal guardianship and adoption are terms that are often used interchangeably, but there are key differences. If you are a parent, or you’re hoping to be a parent one day, it’s important to understand how adoption differs from legal guardianship. In this guide, we’ll outline the differences and help you decide which option is best for you.

Understanding the differences Legal guardianship and adoption share similarities, but they are not the same. While both have the primary aim to provide a child with a stable, loving home environment provided by a non-biological parent, it’s crucial to recognize the differences. These include:

Duration: Legal guardianship is a temporary arrangement while adoption is permanent. In most cases, legal guardians have custody of a child until they reach the age of 18 or their biological parents reclaim custody of the child.

Legal rights: There are key differences in responsibilities and legal rights. If you adopt a child, you assume legal responsibility for that child and the rights of the biological parents are nullified. With legal guardianship, the biological parents retain legal responsibilities for the child. Adoption is a legally binding split between the child and their biological parents. Once a child has been adopted, the biological parents have no visitation rights or child maintenance responsibilities unless there is an open adoption agreement in place.

Process: The adoption process is often much more complex than legal guardianship.

Instant Quote

Which option is right for you?

In most cases, if an individual is deciding between adoption and legal guardianship, it’s because they are in a situation where they cannot care for their child at the moment or they know of a child that needs help. If you are a parent, it’s important to consider both options and to try to make a decision based on what is best for the child. If you are hoping to be a parent, or you want to help a child in need, the decision will come down to the biological parent, but it’s crucial to be aware of the responsibilities involved if you adopt a child or you agree to become a child’s legal guardian.

For parents, it’s important to consider the following:

  • Do you want a relationship with your child in the future?
  • Are you willing and able to support them financially?
  • Are you able to commit to looking after your child in the future before they reach adulthood?

There is no universal right or wrong answer. It’s important to consider the circumstances and prioritize the child. In some cases, legal guardianship is the best option, and in others, adoption is more suitable.


Legal guardianship and adoption both aim to ensure children have access to caring, loving, stable non-biological parents, but there are differences. Adoption is permanent and it eradicates the legal rights of the biological parents. Legal guardianship is temporary, and the biological parents retain legal responsibility for the child. It’s beneficial to seek legal advice if you are considering adoption or legal guardianship.

Disclaimer: This is not legal advice and information may vary between states. Information found on this website is general in nature. Please consult with a lawyer for personal support.

Get matched with the best planner in your area

We’ll connect you with the very best estate planner who will help you prepare an estate plan that sets out your directives for distribution of your assets to your family and friends.